List goes from top row to bottom row. If card company not listed, it is a Topps. Note: I tend to use rookie cards, but if shared card with another player, I use first year player has full card.
| Jim Palmer 1966 | Harmon Killebrew 1955 | Goose Goslin 1927 W560 | Christy Matthewson 1911 T205 | Stan Musial 1940 Play Ball |
| Frank Robinson 1957 | Luis Aparicio 1956 | Jimmy Foxx 1933 Goudey | Cap Anson 1887 Allen Ginter | Ed Plank 1908 E102 |
| Gaylord Perry 1962 | Mike King Kelley 1887 Allen Ginter | Reggie Jackson 1969 | Chief Bender 1909 T206 | Cap Anson 1888 Old Judge |
| Hank Aaron 1954 | Tris Speaker 1911 T205 | Nellie Fox 1951 Bowman | Honus Wagner 1909 T206 | Charles Comiskey 1887 Allen Ginter |
| Billy Williams 1961 | Sandy Koufax 1955 | Joe Cronin 1933 Goudey | Eddie Collins 1908 E102 | Mordecai Brown 1909 T206 |
| Nolan Ryan 1969 | Nap Lajoie 1909 T206 | Brooks Robinson 1957 | Sparky Anderson 1959 | Lefty Grove 1933 DeLong |
| Eddie Mathews 1953 | Rube Marquard 1909 T206 | Joe Morgan 1966 | Roger Bresnahan John McGraw 1912 Hassan | Charlie Geheringer 1934 Goudey |
| Connie Mack 1904 Fan Craze | Joe Tinker Frank Chance 1912 Hassan | Tom Seaver 1968 | George Sisler 1940 Play Ball | Duke Snider 1949 Bowman |
| Tommy LaSorda 1954 | John Evers 1911 T205 | Willie McCovey 1960 | Babe Ruth 1933 Goudey | Willie Mays 1951 Bowman |
| Rod Carew 1968 | Ty Cobb 1909 T206 | Bob Feller 1938 Goudey | Johnny Mize Enos Slaughter 1941 Double Play | Walter Johnson 1915 Cracker Jack |
| Willie Keeler 1911 Turkey Red | Dizzy Dean 1933 Goudey | Ray Dandridge | Yogi Berra 1948 Bowman | Satchell Paige 1948 Leaf |
| Jim Catfish Hunter 1966 | Jackie Robinson 1948 Leaf | Johnny Bench 1969 | * | Lou Brock 1962 |
| Ernie Banks 1954 | Hack Wilson 1933 Goudey | Juan Marichal 1961 | * | Josh Gibson |
| Cy Young 1908 Rose Co. | Frank Frisch 1931 | Leon Day | * | Don Sutton 1967 |
| Al Kaline 1954 | Bob Gibson 1959 | Joe DiMaggio 1941 Play Ball | * | Frank Baker 1907 |
| * | Warren Spahn 1948 Leaf | Whitey Ford 1951 Bowman | * | Ted Williams 1941 Play Ball |
| * | Roberto Clemente 1955 | Grover Alexander 1915 Cracker Jack | Roy Campanella 1949 Bowman | Carl Yastrzemski 1960 |
| * | * | Carl Hubbell 1934 Diamond Star | Monte Irvin 1951 Topps | * |